[J3] [SC22WG5.6706] RE: WG5 letter ballot 1 on Fortran 2023 interpretations

[Hidetoshi IWASHITA]

This is an additional comment to my vote.

As an alternative suggestion, I think it would be better to change
    ROUND shall be present only if ...
to
    ROUND shall appear only if ...
and also change
    16.9.157 OUT_OF_RANGE (X, MOLD [, ROUND])
to

    16.9.157 OUT_OF_RANGE (X, MOLD) or OUT_OF_RANGE (X, MOLD [, ROUND])

This is similar to the argument DIM of 16.9.159 PARITY and 16.9.201 SUM and
the argument COARRAY of 16.9.208 THIS_IMAGE.

Thank you,
Hidetoshi Iwashita


2025年6月9日(月) 16:59 Hidetoshi IWASHITA <iwashita.hideto at gmail.com>:

> Hello everyone,
>
> This is my vote. There were no other comments from the Fortran WG in Japan.
>
> Yes  No   Number    Title
>
> -Y-  ---  F23/003  Conflicting rules for COMMON block names
> -C-  ---  F23/004  OUT_OF_RANGE and ROUND argument
> -Y-  ---  F23/005  Defined assignment/operators and dynamic type
> -Y-  ---  F23/006  Underflow in IEEE_SCALB
> -Y-  ---  F23/008  Real argument I in IEEE_SCALB
> -Y-  ---  F23/009  Coarray subobject of component
> -Y-  ---  F23/010  MOVE_ALLOC with coarray arguments
> -Y-  ---  F23/011  NULL and procedure pointers
> -Y-  ---  F23/012  Coarray correspondence in DEALLOCATE
> -Y-  ---  F23/013  BOZ literals in interoperable enumerators
> -Y-  ---  F23/015  Coindexed objects in structure constructors
> -Y-  ---  F23/016  Segments associated with allocation
> -Y-  ---  F23/017  CFI_establish nonalloc nonpointer null base address
> -Y-  ---  F23/018  Correspondence of unallocated coarrays
>
>
> Comment to F23/004.
> As well as changing "be present" to "appear",
> "ROUND" should be changed to
> "the actual argument corresponding to ROUND".
> As a result, I think
>     ROUND shall be present only if ...
> should be changed to
>     The actual argument corresponding to ROUND shall appear only if ...
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://mailman.j3-fortran.org/pipermail/j3/attachments/20250612/72c095dc/attachment.htm>