[J3] (SC22WG5.6053) Response to comments draft

John Reid John.Reid at stfc.ac.uk
Thu Jun 21 14:28:50 EDT 2018


Steve,

Steve Lionel via J3 wrote:
> In the WG5 folder on the J3 "Meeting Files" page is N2153-1.pdf, a draft 
> of the response to comments on the DIS. Please review this and get back 
> to me (please respond to just me, not the list) by Friday, June 22. 
> Thanks, and thanks also for making my first meeting as Convenor so 
> productive.

Here are my comments so far (will do more tomorrow):

DE 08 Accepted with modification.

DE 09 Rejected.

JP 23 Accepted with major change.

GB 35 Accepted with different change.

GB 37 Accepted with different change.

GB 38 Accepted with modification.

US 39 Rejected as redundant with para 4.

US 40 Rejected because assumed-type is meant to be usable
       with sequence association.

US 41 Accepted with modification.

GB 42 Accepted with modification.

GB 47 Accepted with extra edit.

GB 48 Accepted with extra edit.

GB 50 Accepted with modification.

GB 51 Accepted with modification.

GB 56 Accepted with modification.

GB 58 Accepted with modification.

JP 66 Accepted with modification.

** 77 18-220r1.

GB 83 Accepted with modification.

Cheers,

John.


More information about the J3 mailing list