(j3.2006) (SC22WG5.4138) Result of the FCD ballot on Fortran2008

[John Reid]

Van Snyder wrote:
> The file SC22-N-4487_CSK.doc that is mentioned in N1801 as a "Comment
> File" from North Korea is just a ballot that says "Yes without comment,"
> so we don't need it either on the server on its own, or as part of
> another file.
> 
> It was un-handy that the document that became N1801 had links to local
> files, probably on the computer of whomever prepared the file.  It would
> have been more helpful if SC22 had prepared it with links that landed
> somewhere useful, so we could have determined immediately that the
> "comment" from North Korea was vacuous.
> 
> Portugal and Kazakhstan are listed in N1801 as having provided comments,
> but there is no comment file listed for either of them, and no comment
> from either of them in N1802.  Should we assume there actually are no
> comments from them to which we need to reply?

I have asked the SC22 secretary, but she is out of the office until Friday.

John.