(j3.2006) (SC22WG5.4365) WG5 informal ballot re Interop. TR

John Reid John.Reid
Thu Dec 2 14:39:04 EST 2010

1. Is the above revised schedule acceptable?


2. Do you have any comments on N1838? Please give special attention
to the UTIs. For each significant change, please provide text for a new

UTI TR2 (page 10). I favour option (2): add an additional character length 
member. Reason: this is the most straightforward way to solve the problem.

Minor comments:

3:16-17. On line 16, add "one of" before "the intrinsic"; on line 17, change 
"or" to "and".

5:21+. Reword NOTE to
"Because the type and type parameters of an assumed-type dummy argument are 
assumed from its effective argument, neither can be used for generic resolution. 
Similarly, the rank of an assumed-rank dummy argument cannot be used for generic 

9:30. Add period at line end.

11:3. Change "is equal to (CFI_index_t)-2" by "shall have the value -2".

14:7-8. Replace "Pointer objects" by "A pointer object".

15:34. Add comma after "pointer".

15:44-45. Move the sentence "Since ..." to a note, since it is just explanation.

More information about the J3 mailing list