(j3.2006) 08-145r1

Van Snyder Van.Snyder
Mon Oct 6 22:41:15 EDT 2008

On Tue, 2008-10-07 at 11:05 +0900, Malcolm Cohen wrote:
> Dan Nagle wrote:
> > Hi,
> >
> > So is there an r1, or not?
> >   
> Not.
> > If there is, it should be in the archive.
> >   
> It's not in the archive, it's not in the minutes, therefore it does not 
> exist.
> Van produced a draft r1, but didn't submit it because we weren't going 
> to do anything with it.  I suggest the mention of it in N1741 is a 
> simple typo/thinko.

It's not a typo, it's a thinko.

> There are various edits with an antecedent of 08-145 in 08-019.  None of 
> them are marked with 08-145r1.
> I think it's rather late to be creating papers from 2 meetings ago...
> ...and the mention of 08-145anything and inclusion of its edits in N1741 
> is entirely spurious (well, if you believe "summarize material from all 
> papers that passed at J3 meetings 184 and 185, and that included 
> edits").  The 08-145 edits were never "passed by a J3 meeting", the 
> paper had a number of editorial suggestions that I put directly into 
> 08-019 (probably modified)  and others that I rejected.

It shouldn't have been mentioned in N1741.

Sorry for the confusion.


More information about the J3 mailing list