(j3.2006) J3 Fortran interp letter ballot #17 - due 25-Jul-2008

[Whitlock, Stan]

The following Fortran interpretations are being balloted:

 

Yes  No   Number    Title

 

-Y--  ---  F95/0074  TARGET dummy arguments and POINTER expressions

-Y--  ---  F95/0102  mask-expr evaluated only once

-Y--  ---  F03/0049  Separators in list-directed output involving

                             UDDTIO

-Y--  ---  F03/0071  Subroutine/function ambiguity in generics

-Y--  ---  F03/0073  C interop of dummy procedures

-Y--  ---  F03/0074  Type mismatch for C character arguments

-Y--  ---  F03/0075  C interop of derived types with array components

-Y--  ---  F03/0076  Scope of Fortran names of procedures with binding

                             labels

-Y--  ---  F03/0077  LBOUND of array structure component

-Y--  ---  F03/0081  F edit descriptor with field width 0

-Y--  ---  F03/0082  VALUE in place of INTENT for pure procedure dummy

                             arguments

-Y--  ---  F03/0087  Entry names as dummy procedure arguments

-Y--  ---  F03/0098  Does allocate with source= define subcomponents?

-C--  ---  F03/0112  attributes allowed for dummy arguments in defined

                             assignments

 

YES Comment on F03/0112 by Stan Whitlock:

I do not agree with Bill Long and Dan Nagle that the discussion
contradicts

the edit.  The discussion says:

 

  "Such a restriction for the second argument has no effect since the
right

   argument is treated as an expression enclosed in parentheses which
would

   have neither attribute but it does no harm.  An edit is provided."

 

I find that a satisfactory explanation.  But since there is some
confusion about

our actions, I suggest we change that part of the discussion to clarify
what we're

 doing:

 

  "Such a restriction for the second argument has no effect since the
right

   argument is treated as an expression enclosed in parentheses which
would

   have neither attribute.  But such a restriction does no harm so an
edit to

    state that restriction is provided."

 

-Y--  ---  F03/0117  STOP executed via function in input/output list

 

Thanks                                      /Stan

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://j3-fortran.org/pipermail/j3/attachments/20080625/f512e3e7/attachment.html